Skip to content
Esports Gamer

Murdochs Allegedly Endorsed Fox News Plan to Broadcast 2020 Election Fraud Claims, Hearing Reveals.

During a pivotal court hearing on Tuesday, a attorney for the voting technology company Smartmatic contended that senior executives at Fox News, specifically Rupert and Lachlan Murdoch, sanctioned a conscious strategy to adopt baseless assertions of election fraud promoted by Donald Trump.

“Their core viewers, their bread and butter, abandoned them,” declared J Erik Connolly, Smartmatic's lawyer. “So what do they do? They return back to what they know best: they go back to misinformation, political propaganda and xenophobia. The election story and the election fraud claims was the ideal tool for them to get back onto their core messaging.”

A Massive Defamation Case Hangs in the Balance

In courtroom presentations, both sides urged with Judge David B Cohen to decide on critical elements of Smartmatic's $2.7bn defamation lawsuit ahead of a potential trial next year. The plaintiff argues that Fox leaders hatched a plan to “shift” to Trump's claims to recapture disaffected viewers.

The Network's Strong Denial

K Winn Allen, speaking for the network, strongly contested these accusations. “No disinformation campaign was authorized,” he said. “It is completely false. The evidence does not support it. It is nonsense. It was fabricated by opposing counsel.”

He added that the Murdochs, who ultimately controlled the network, “issued no directives to cover Smartmatic or the election fraud allegations.”

The Core Legal Hurdle: Proving “Actual Malice”

For Smartmatic to prevail, the voting firm will have to demonstrate that important personnel at Fox News knew the fraud claims were false but permitted them to be aired regardless. Through legal motions, Smartmatic has pointed to internal communications showing personalities like Jeanine Pirro and Maria Bartiromo voicing skepticism about the claims while also expressing a desire to assist Trump.

The network's attorney countered that Smartmatic has “wildly inflated” its value and the projected damages from the broadcasts. Fox maintains its hosts were merely reporting on newsworthy allegations from the president's associates, not promoting them.

“This lawsuit is not truly about Fox's coverage of the 2020 election,” the Fox lawyer stated. “It's about Smartmatic's attempt to capitalize on comments made by the president's lawyers to rescue its business viability.”

A Previous Case Looms Large

The arguments closely mirror the prior defamation lawsuit brought by Dominion Voting Systems against Fox. In that matter, a judge's pre-trial rulings proved critical, ruling that Fox's broadcasts were false and defamatory per se.

That ruling was later cited as a key factor in Fox's choice to settle with Dominion for $787.5 million. A former Fox legal officer noted that the judge's pre-trial rulings had “severely limited” the company's ability to defend itself at trial.

Judge Cohen's Position

The presiding judge gave no clear hints of his leaning but informed Smartmatic's lawyer that proving “knowledge of falsity” for a summary judgment would be a “hard sell.” He stated he intended to examine all relevant television segments before making a decision.

“I believe I have more than enough material, data, legal briefs, charts, charts and all I need to make my ruling,” he told the two sides in the case.

Written by

Brandy Phillips

A passionate esports journalist with over a decade of experience covering major tournaments and interviewing top gamers worldwide.

Esports Gamer

Type to search articles.